|
|
Agreement on guilt and punishment
Skolil, Ondřej ; Bohuslav, Lukáš (advisor) ; Vokoun, Rudolf (referee)
Agreement on guilt and punishment - Abstract The topic of this rigorous thesis is an institute of an agreement on guilt and punishment, which is one of the diversions in criminal proceedings that is regulated by our criminal law. Given that the institute of the agreement on guilt and punishment is conceptually subordinated to just mentioned concept of diversions in criminal proceedings, this thesis does not deal only with the institute of agreement on guilt and punishment, but also with all other diversions in criminal proceedings, which are regulated by our criminal law. The main usage goal of the institute of an agreement on guilt and punishment is to simplify and speed up the entire criminal proceedings, when thanks to a conclusion of an agreement on guilt and punishment, the entire criminal proceedings can come to a successful conclusion relatively quickly. This thesis is divided into three chapters. The first chapter deals with the concept of diversion in criminal proceedings, the principle of so-called restorative justice, as well as with all the individual diversions in criminal proceedings (with the exception of the institute of the agreement on guilt and punishment). Part of this chapter are also statistics, thanks to which the reader of this thesis can find out to what extent the diversion is used...
|
|
|
An agreement on guilt and punishment
Bořuta, Jan ; Jelínek, Jiří (advisor) ; Vanduchová, Marie (referee)
This thesis is dedicated to legal institute of plea bargaining which has been adopted to Czech criminal procedure law on September 1, 2012. The plea bargaining law in the Czech Republic is highly influenced by plea bargaining practise used in different forms in various common law jurisdictions. The thesis is divided into three basic chapters. First chapter of this thesis describes overall background and reasons for adoption of plea bargaining into Czech law. In this chapter the author presents and analyses reasons and desired results the Czech legislature pursues by adoption of plea bargaining and its usage in practise. Second chapter provides a critical view of relation of plea bargaining with the rest of Czech criminal procedure regulation, especially an interaction of plea bargaining with fundamental principles of criminal procedure. Third chapter focuses on whole procedure related to plea bargaining as regulated by current law. This chapter describes and analyses positions of all parties to the process concerned, plea bargaining negotiation process itself and its legal limits. Furthermore it depicts and examines the process of court hearing and position and role of the court within it. The third chapter also concerns several legal measures laid down in order to secure compliance of the plea...
|
|
|
Settlement in criminal proceedings
Skolil, Ondřej ; Bohuslav, Lukáš (advisor) ; Vokoun, Rudolf (referee)
Settlement in criminal proceeding - Abstract The topic of this diploma thesis is settlement in criminal proceedings, which is one of the diversions, which has had its position in our criminal procedure law for more than 20 years. The settlement is a diversion, which contains the most restorative justice principles. This is the reason, why the text of this thesis does not only deal with the settlement itself, but also with other diversions, as well as with the restorative justice principles. The main objective of this principle is not punishing the offender, but restoring the disturbed relationships between the offender and the victim. Despite the fact that the settlement is beneficial for defendant, because it leads to cessation of prosecution, for victim, who has an easier access to obtain their compensation and also for the whole society, because it prevents the defendant to commit other crimes, it is not used so often in practice as much as for example conditional suspension of criminal prosecution. The thesis is divided into three chapters. The first chapter deals with the term diversion, restorative justice function principles and then with all types of diversions, which are enacted by our criminal procedure law. The statistics then show sometimes giant differences in the usage of particular types of...
|
|
|
Criminal Warrant
Kubíčková, Michaela ; Galovcová, Ingrid (advisor) ; Tlapák Navrátilová, Jana (referee)
Criminal warrant represents a decision in criminal matters which is also special manner of criminal procedure. A single judge is empowered to issue a criminal warrant without trying the matter in the main trial if the facts are reliably proved by evidences. It is regulated by the section 314e and following of the Criminal Procedure Code. It diverse from regular criminal proceeding, because it is in fact a way of simplified and written procedure. These characteristics are also the reasons why criminal warrant is criticized by professionals. Such a diversion from regular criminal proceeding is being called as a violation of right to a fair trial by many authors. Considering such institute from the point of view of basic principles of criminal proceeding, including right to fair trial, emerge in each of six chapters of this thesis, while it forms a crucial and final part of this thesis. At the beginning is a criminal warrant introduced as a decision in a criminal matters, a special manner in criminal proceeding and diversion of criminal procedure. In order to understand applicable legal regulation of criminal warrant which is described in chapter three, the second chapter is designated to historical review. In the fourth chapter of this thesis I deal with rights of appeal, including a statement of...
|
|
|
Agreement on Guilt and Punishment
Zaoralová, Petra ; Jelínek, Jiří (advisor) ; Herczeg, Jiří (referee)
The submitted thesis is addressed to the institute of Agreement on Guilt and Punishment which has been adopted to the Czech criminal proceedings by the amendment to the Criminal Procedure Code, the Act no. 193/2012 Coll., as effective of 1 September 2012. The inspiration of implementing the new procedural institute was drawn from the Anglo-Saxon institute of "Guilty Plea" which was modified and adapted to the Czech legal environment. The Czech legislator has significantly diverged from fundamental theoretical grounds commonly recognized in other countries abroad while setting up such application conditions which has legitimately risen debates questioning the position of the Agreement on Guilt and Punishment in the Czech legal system itself. The thesis is divided into six chapters. The introductory chapter deals with systematic and ideological foundations of plea bargaining and summarizes the reasons why has been originally Anglo-Saxon institute progressively implemented to many continental legal systems across Europe. Second chapter offers the summary of valuable international case law and presents the plea bargaining process from the view of European Court of Human Rights. Third chapter focuses on legislation related to the Agreement on Guilt and Punishment in other continental law jurisdictions laying...
|
|
|
An agreement on guilt and punishment
Bořuta, Jan ; Jelínek, Jiří (advisor) ; Vanduchová, Marie (referee)
This thesis is dedicated to legal institute of plea bargaining which has been adopted to Czech criminal procedure law on September 1, 2012. The plea bargaining law in the Czech Republic is highly influenced by plea bargaining practise used in different forms in various common law jurisdictions. The thesis is divided into three basic chapters. First chapter of this thesis describes overall background and reasons for adoption of plea bargaining into Czech law. In this chapter the author presents and analyses reasons and desired results the Czech legislature pursues by adoption of plea bargaining and its usage in practise. Second chapter provides a critical view of relation of plea bargaining with the rest of Czech criminal procedure regulation, especially an interaction of plea bargaining with fundamental principles of criminal procedure. Third chapter focuses on whole procedure related to plea bargaining as regulated by current law. This chapter describes and analyses positions of all parties to the process concerned, plea bargaining negotiation process itself and its legal limits. Furthermore it depicts and examines the process of court hearing and position and role of the court within it. The third chapter also concerns several legal measures laid down in order to secure compliance of the plea...
|
|
|
Settlement in criminal proceedings
Hegerová, Klára ; Bohuslav, Lukáš (advisor) ; Vokoun, Rudolf (referee)
The topic of this diploma thesis is the settlement in criminal proceedings, one of diversions, or also alternatives to typical course and outcome of criminal proceedings. The settlement was incorporated into the Czech Criminal Procedure Code by the amendment n. 152/1995 Sb. with the effect on 1st September 1995. The settlement is an institute of criminal procedure law originating in restorative justice principles and its goal is to restore affected relationship between the defendant and the victim. Then proceedings of the settlement should not serve only to compensate the victim, as is sometimes perceived by the public, but also to clarify causes of the conflict during the active participation of both parties and to assume personal responsibility for the crime committed which may have significant effects in terms of criminal prevention. Despite the fact that the settlement is a form of diversion beneficial to the defendant (it leads to cessation of prosecution), victim (it is faster to obtain the compensation) and society (prevention from committing other crimes, relieving courts in favour of complex and serious crimes), it is rarely used in practice. In the first chapter I generally deal with the concept of diversions in criminal proceedings, their fundamental characteristics and common features...
|
guest ::
