|
|
Alternatives to unconditional sentence of imprisonment
Košárková, Barbora ; Šelleng, Dalibor (advisor) ; Hořák, Jaromír (referee)
Alternatives to unconditional sentence of imprisonment This thesis examines selected alternative punishments to imprisonment. In particular, it focuses on home arrest (including electronic monitoring), community service and fines, in the context of the Czech and Dutch legislation. The first chapter describes the concept and purpose of punishment, while the first subchapter introduces the different concepts of punishment and the second subchapter presents the different theories of punishment, the purpose of punishment and its use in the legal system of the Czech Republic. The next three chapters are devoted to restorative justice, probation and mediation and finally to the concept of alternative punishment in general. Chapter five focuses on the regulation of alternative sentencing in the Czech Republic. It is divided into six subchapters, where, after a general introduction and introduction of an important amendment to the Criminal Code. The following three subchapters cover the punishment of house arrest, community service and fine. These subchapters are then divided into the historical development of the punishment in question, its characteristics and definition, the imposition of the punishment in question and the imposition of adequate duties and restrictions, the conversion of the punishment...
|
|
|
Punishment of house arrest, its execution and control
Šarman, Dominik ; Tlapák Navrátilová, Jana (advisor) ; Mulák, Jiří (referee)
The punishment of house arrest, its execution and control Abstract The thesis deals with the punishment of house arrest and topics closely related to it, especially its execution and control. The thesis elaborates on the findings of the relevant literature, namely textbook, commentary and monographic literature, and draws on scholarly articles that are an important source of information for this topic. There is also an analysis of available case law and statistical data. The thesis also widely uses internet sources. The thesis attempts to provide a comprehensive treatment of the topic by introducing the issue of punishment, followed by a detailed treatment of the legal regulation of all relevant phases of the imposition and execution of house arrest in the Czech Republic. Throughout the thesis, the author tries to present the pros of this punishment, analyses the shortcomings and facts that hinder the wider use of the punishment in the Czech Republic and reflects on its future direction. The thesis is divided into seven chapters, which proceed from the theoretical basis to the legal treatment of the institute itself and then deal with the execution and control of the execution of the sentence of house arrest, as well as other related issues. The introductory chapters offer an insight into the issue of...
|
|
|
Alternatives to unconditional sentence of imprisonment
Lukáš, Marek ; Šelleng, Dalibor (advisor) ; Mulák, Jiří (referee)
The subject of this master's thesis is a description of the current legislation and application practice of selected punishments that represent the main alternatives to the imposition of unconditional prison sentences. These punishments are house arrest, community service, financial penalty, suspended sentence of imprisonment and suspended sentence of imprisonment with supervision. Since each of the abovementioned punishments could be the subject of a separate master thesis, this thesis does not aim to describe the subject matter in detail, but rather to present the individual institutes in their mutual context, to compare their characteristic features, purpose, conditions, specifics of their execution, as well as their use in judicial practice. The thesis consists of eight chapters, three of which are of a general nature, four deal with individual penalties and the last one is devoted to de lege ferenda proposals. The first chapter defines the very concept of criminal punishment and its purpose. A substantial part of the chapter is devoted to the historical development of penology theories regarding the purpose of the criminal punishment, with special focus on the transition from a retributive and punitive view of punishment to the concept of restorative justice. The second chapter focuses on the...
|
|
| |
|
|
House arrest
Kasalová, Petra ; Tlapák Navrátilová, Jana (advisor) ; Vanduchová, Marie (referee)
The presented thesis deals with the alternative punishment of house arrest, which became the part of the system of criminal sanctions when the new Penal Code came into force on 1st January 2010. The purpose of this thesis is to summarize current valid and effective legislation of this institute, to describe its weaknesses, to evaluate the current judicial experience in imposing the punishment of house arrest and to suggest possible improvements of the current legislation considering the final conclusions. The introductory part of this thesis is divided into two chapters focusing on approaching the basic and the most important terms, especially the term of punishment and its purpose, alternative punishment, restorative justice and its principles. Related subjects such as criminal theory, the principles of sentencing and criminal system are explained to put the issue in a broader context and to clarify them. The first part of this thesis is concluded with the interpretations of the development of alternative punishment in our legislation and the foundations of the new codification of substantive criminal law. The second part of this thesis is focused in detail on the issue of the legislation of the punishment of house arrest. It is divided into four chapters, whose goal is a detailed analysis of...
|
|
|
Alternative sanctions as a way of solution of woman criminality
Vrbický, Filip ; Cejp, Martin (advisor) ; Prasek, Petr (referee)
Thesis focuses on alternative sanctions as a way of solution of woman criminality. It describes woman criminality, its distinctiveness, by which this criminality differs from man criminality and it also introduces history of this field. It calls attention for special treatment of women, who are due to their anti-social behavior sent to prison and it lists specifics related to their imprisonment. It calls attention for problem of short-term imprisonment and need for finding alternative ways of offenders' punishments. It provides insight into the field of alternative sanctions and considering social role of woman it gives arguments for widening of applying alternative sanctions for this group of offenders. It tries to state in which ways this widening should be reached.
|
|
|
Current issues on imposing a pecuniary punishment and its performance
Hlavatá, Michaela ; Jelínek, Jiří (advisor) ; Heranová, Simona (referee)
This diploma thesis deals with the issue of a pecuniary punishment with a focus on the latest amendment in this area made by the Act No. 333/2020 Coll. The aim of this diploma thesis is to provide an analysis of the current legislation of pecuniary punishment, including an analysis of the causes of the low number of pecuniary punishments imposed. For the evaluation of the legislation the author used academic literature, case law and statistical data, while these sources showed that there is still room for improvement of the effective legal regulation. To understand the broader context, the reader will find in the first part general introduction to the issue of a pecuniary punishment. In this part the diploma thesis also deals with the advantages and disadvantages of a pecuniary punishment and analyses practice. The following second part focuses on regulation of pecuniary punishment in the substantial law. It describes the legal requirements for the imposition of a pecuniary punishment, deals with the drawbacks of the daily-fine system and also defines the range of crimes punishable by a pecuniary punishment. The third part deals with the procedural regulation of a pecuniary punishment. In particular, it focuses on the role of the public prosecutor in imposing a pecuniary punishment, draws attention...
|
|
|
Alternatives to unconditional sentence of imprisonment and their comparison with the French legislation
Kocourková, Kristýna ; Šelleng, Dalibor (advisor) ; Pelc, Vladimír (referee)
This thesis deals with alternatives to unconditional imprisonment. Since this is a very extensive topic, I have focused only on alternative sentences in the narrower sense of the term, namely conditional conviction, conditional conviction with supervision, house arrest, community service and financial punishment. The aim of this thesis is to analyse the Czech lawful legislation of alternatives to unconditional imprisonment, to compare it with selected French alternative sentences and to propose changes de lege ferenda. The thesis consists of an introduction, five chapters and a conclusion. The first chapter deals with the concept of punishment and its purpose. At the same time, this chapter outlines a general introduction to alternative punishments in Czech and French legislation. The second chapter deals with institutes related to restorative justice, namely probation and mediation. This chapter also describes the organisation of the Probation and Mediation Service. The third chapter focuses on individual Czech alternative punishments in the narrower sense. Individual subchapters are ordered according to the systematic of law. Within each subchapter the sentence is characterized, followed by a list of conditions under which the sentence can be imposed, as well as the conditions for the execution...
|
|
|
A pecuniary punishment - its advantages, drawbacks and application
Šeba, Jan ; Jelínek, Jiří (advisor) ; Šelleng, Dalibor (referee)
In the Western States, a pecuniary punishment represents a proven alternative to (un)conditional imprisonment. By joint effort of the Supreme Public Prosecutor's Office and the Supreme Court, the pecuniary punishment has become a trend over the last few years also in the Czech Republic. Why should criminal justice bodies strive for more frequent imposition of the pecuniary punishment? In which cases is the pecuniary punishment an appropriate criminal sanction? And how is, or rather should be, the pecuniary punishment imposed and enforced? The submitted master's thesis draws attention to the obstacles of effective legal regulation and its inconsistent application. It deals with substantive and procedural aspects of the matter, relevant case law and statistical data. Conscious of the limits of comparisons in criminal law, the author also takes into account the law of Germany, Austria and the Netherlands. The first part of the thesis deals with the pecuniary punishment in general. The diploma candidate describes its purpose, position in the system of criminal sanctions and basic characteristics. A closer look is taken at the new way to satisfy the injured person, which was introduced on 1 January 2018 by Act No. 59/2017 Sb., on the use of financial resources from proprietary criminal sanctions imposed...
|
|
|
Alternatives to unconditional sentence of imprisonment
Drastich, Michal ; Vanduchová, Marie (advisor) ; Jelínek, Jiří (referee)
My master thesis deals with the topic of alternatives to unconditional sentence of imprisonment. It is a vast topic, thus I have focused on alternative sentences in the narrower sense of the term, in other words, suspended sentence of imprisonment, suspended sentence of imprisonment with surveillance, community service, financial penalty and house arrest. The goal of this thesis is to discuss lawful legislation of alternative sentences, to evaluate their practical usage and potentially, to suggest changes de lege ferenda, which could lead to higher rate of application of these sentences. The thesis consists of an introduction, seven chapters and a conclusion, where the three initial chapters are written in general sense. The first chapter is concerned about the term and the purpose of sentence. The concept of restorative justice, which provides us another way how to react to the criminal acting, is introduced as a part of this chapter, too. The second chapter focuses on unconditional sentence of imprisonment and issues of the short-term sentence. Furthermore, the term of alternative sentence is explained, including a brief commentary on actions of international organizations in this area, namely Council of Europe and UN. The development of these sentences in the Czech republic after 1989 is...
|
guest ::
