|
|
Participation
Semerád, Vojtěch ; Pelc, Vladimír (advisor) ; Hořák, Jaromír (referee)
The submitted master thesis deals with the issue of regulation of participation in a criminal offence, i.e. criminal liability of persons who participated in a criminal offence, as a wide range of perspectives on the question of how to build a system of criminal liability of persons participating in a criminal offence can be observed across legal systems. Thus, the primary aim of this thesis was to analyse the current legal regulation of participation in the Czech Republic, which allowed to identify the strengths as well as the problematic points of the Czech regulation. Since an integral part of the analysis is a de lege ferenda perspective, the logical outcome is to compare the results of the analysis with the regulation of participation in France and to look for intersections and differences between the two regulations. The thesis is internally divided into 4 chapters. The first chapter provides a general introduction to the issue of criminal complicity, i.e. it includes the definition and differentiation of participation and other forms of criminal complicity, which has led to the creation of a working framework within which the issues of the following chapters will be analysed. The second chapter is devoted to two theoretical approaches to the regulation of participation, namely monistic and...
|
|
|
Participation
Lindnerová, Adéla ; Pelc, Vladimír (advisor) ; Hořák, Jaromír (referee)
Participation Abstract The aim of this diploma thesis is especially to identify the advantages and disadvantages of individual approaches to regulation of participation, to set out the main attributes of participation in the Czech criminal law, including its main deficiencies, and to present possible inspiring solutions for their elimination by presenting a different model of regulation abroad. Participation as one of the forms of criminal collaboration is approached slightly differently by each legislation. However, the legislations usually agree that the participant's actions must be punished in a certain way. Although the participant does not partake in the fulfillment of the constituent elements of the crime by its own actions, its influence on the crime itself may be significant. The reason for choosing this topic is mainly the still unresolved situation regarding the institute of participation in the Czech Criminal Code and a large amount of criticism of the current regulation. Although the Criminal Code was newly adopted in 2009 and the possibility of correcting the deficiencies of the participation was obvious, professional discussions did not take place, and in the end a regulation that to a certain extent copied the previous criticized one, was adopted. In addition to the introduction and...
|
|
|
Participation
Klabanová, Andrea ; Pelc, Vladimír (advisor) ; Hořák, Jaromír (referee)
This diploma thesis provides to the reader an analysis of one of the most complex institutes of substantive criminal law - participation. Its aim is to focus mainly on the current legislation of participation, but also to criticize it and to propose the changes in legislation. Apart from the introduction and conclusion, the thesis consists of a total of six parts. The first part of the thesis is devoted to defining the concept participation together with concepts associated with participation. First of all, the concept criminal cooperation is defined, in which the division of participation we can find, and then the division of participation itself is discussed. The second part analyzes individual conditions and principles of participation, on which this institute is built. Accessority of participation, which is crucial for this institute, is discussed in more detail. The third part deals with individual forms of participation. Firstly the conditions of criminal liability are analyzed from the most serious form to the least serious one. For each individual form there are then discussed the specifics of the form associated. The chapter related to organizing distinguishes this from an organized group and an organized criminal group. At abetting there is the institute of agent provocateur and hiring...
|
|
|
Participation in Criminal Law
Pelc, Vladimír ; Jelínek, Jiří (advisor) ; Říha, Jiří (referee)
1 Abstract The submitted rigorous thesis comprehensively deals with the institute of participation in the offense in Czech criminal law (hereinafter referred as "complicity"). The thesis particularly focuses on de lege lata interpretation of the complicity, i.e. on existing legislation, Act. No. 40/2009 Coll., Criminal Code. The text contains numerous proposals de lege ferenda, which results from the critical approach to current regulation of the complicity in Czech legal system. The participation is a traditional and complicated topic of the criminal law doctrine. The issue of criminal liability for participation in the offense is one of the most complicated issues of criminal law theory and practice. The complexity of problem stems primarily from the fact, that the institute of complicity prohibits a conduct, which is not ordinarily directly fulfilling the basic elements of the crime offense. Therefore it is necessary to derive the actions of an accomplice from the actions of an offender, who always (at least partially) fulfils those basic elements of the crime. We can also say that similarly, depending on the different systems of complicity, the criminal liability of accomplice is more or less based on the criminal liability of offender. The work is divided into seven chapters, which are further...
|
guest ::
