|
|
Independence and impartiality of the Court of Arbitration for sport in the context of the Pechstein case
Plevková, Tereza ; Štědroň, Bohumír (advisor) ; Exner, Jan (referee)
Title: Independence and impartiality of the Court of Arbitration for sport in the context of the Pechstein case Objectives: The main objective of this bachelor thesis is to identify a structural imbalance in the Court of arbitration for sport and to devise some suggestions for a new reform of CAS. Methods: This thesis used the method of analysis of the secondary data from documents of various formats, specifically different variants of web resources and books. Results: I have found that the Court of arbitration for sport has several structural imbalances in these parts: Independence of ICAS, Independence of individual arbitrators, Information on arbitrators, Publication of CAS awards, Publication of administrative documents and Access to justice. Because of that I proposed eight suggestions, which could eliminate partiality of the CAS. Keywords: independence, impartiality, the Claudia Pechstein case, Court of Arbitration for sport
|
|
|
Proportionality of a four-year ineligibility for the first intentional anti-doping rule violations and its impact on professional athletes' careers
Plevková, Tereza ; Exner, Jan (advisor) ; Štědroň, Bohumír (referee)
Title: Proportionality of a four-year ineligibility for the first intentional anti-doping rule violations and its impact on professional athletes' careers Objectives: The aim of this thesis is to ascertain whether the four-year ineligibility for the first intentional anti-doping rule violations has liquidation impact on professional athletes' careers. Methods: For quantitative research, I have used the electronic interrogation method and for qualitative research the in-depth semi-structured interview. Results: I have found that most athletes really do perceive a four-year ineligibility for the first intentional anti-doping rule violations as disproportionate. Only 24 % of surveyed athletes said that a four-year ineligibility is an appropriate punishment. 82 % of surveyed athletes would end their careers after receiving a four-year ineligibility, and just 30 % of them think that It's realistic to go back to an active career after a four-year break. Moreover, athletes have consistently said that the most crucial obstacles to their return are financial distress, loss of motivation and lack of racing mode. On the basis of these results, I have also developed my own solution to ineligibility for the first intentional anti-doping rule violations. Keywords: proportionality, sanction, ineligibility,...
|
|
|
Independence and impartiality of the Court of Arbitration for sport in the context of the Pechstein case
Plevková, Tereza ; Štědroň, Bohumír (advisor) ; Exner, Jan (referee)
Title: Independence and impartiality of the Court of Arbitration for sport in the context of the Pechstein case Objectives: The main objective of this bachelor thesis is to identify a structural imbalance in the Court of arbitration for sport and to devise some suggestions for a new reform of CAS. Methods: This thesis used the method of analysis of the secondary data from documents of various formats, specifically different variants of web resources and books. Results: I have found that the Court of arbitration for sport has several structural imbalances in these parts: Independence of ICAS, Independence of individual arbitrators, Information on arbitrators, Publication of CAS awards, Publication of administrative documents and Access to justice. Because of that I proposed eight suggestions, which could eliminate partiality of the CAS. Keywords: independence, impartiality, the Claudia Pechstein case, Court of Arbitration for sport
|
guest ::
